Showing posts with label Project Management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Project Management. Show all posts

Sunday, May 18, 2008

Productivity Objectives

If your business doesn't have productivity objectives, it doesn't have direction.  If your business doesn't have productivity measurements, it doesn't have control.  In The Essential Drucker: The Best of Sixty Years of Peter Drucker's Essential Writings on Management, Peter Drucker explains that productivity is the best yardstick for comparing management effectiveness.

Productivity is the Best Yardstick
According to Drucker, productivity is the best tool for comparing management effectiveness across your enterprise:

A productivity measurement is the best yardstick for comparing management of different units within an enterprise, and for comparing managements of different enterprises.

Productivity is the Degree to Which Resources are Utilized and Their Yield
The quality of management differentiates one business from another in the same field.  Drucker writes:

All businesses have access to pretty much the same resources. Except for the rare monopoly situation, the only thing that differentiates one business from another in any given field is the quality of its management on all levels. The first measurement of this critical factor is productivity, that is, the degree to which resources are utilized and their yield.

Continuous Productivity Improvement
Management's most important job is continuous productivity improvement.  Drucker writes:

The continual improvement of productivity is one of management’s most important jobs. It is also one of the most difficult; for productivity is a balance among a diversity of factors, few of which are easily definable or clearly measurable.

Labor is Only One Factor
According to Drucker, there's three major resources when you're considering productivity objectives: land, labor and capital.  Drucker writes that you can't let labor make the other resources less productive:

Labor is only one of the three factors of production. And if productivity of labor is accomplished by making the other resources less productive, there is actually loss of productivity.

Objectives are Direction, Measurement is Control
According to Drucker, productivity is central:

Productivity is a difficult concept, but it is central. Without productivity objectives, a business does not have direction. Without productivity measurements, it does not have control.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Productivity is the best tool for comparing effectiveness.
  • The quality of management differentiates one business from another in the same field.
  • Management's most important job is continuous productivity improvement.

I think the meta-point is, assuming both businesses produce effective results, the more efficient one wins in the long run.  That's consistent with my experience.

I think another important point here is that if you focus on your productivity, you can usually find a lot of opportunity for innovation in your processes.

My Related Posts

Thursday, May 15, 2008

Action Commitments

All talk, no action?  Good ideas, but no results?  A common problem is a lack of action commitments.  If you don't break your decisions down into effective actions with owners, don't expect results.  If you have owners for actions, but you haven't equipped them for success, don't be surprised when things fall through.  Turning decisions into effective actions requires thoughtful work assignments.  In The Essential Drucker: The Best of Sixty Years of Peter Drucker's Essential Writings on Management, Peter Drucker explains how to turn decisions into actions.

Decisions are Not Effective Without Action Commitments
According to Drucker, simply making decisions doesn't help if they aren't turned into action:

Converting the decision into action is the fourth major element in the decision process.  While thinking through the boundary conditions is the most difficult step in decision-making, converting the decisions into effective action is usually the most time-consuming one.  Yet  a decision will not become effective unless the action commitments have been built into the decision from the start. 

Until There’s Work Assignments, There’s Only Good Intentions
Drucker says it's actions that count:

In fact, no decision has been made unless carrying it out in specific steps has become someone’s work assignment and responsibility.  Until then, there are only good intentions.

A Declaration of What You’re Not Going to Do
Drucker tells us why people doubt policy statements from above:

That is the trouble with so many policy statements, especially of business; they contain no action commitment.  To carry them out is no one’s specific work and responsibility.  No wonder that the people in the organization tend to view these statements cynically if not as declarations of what top management is really not going to do.

Questions To Help Convert a Decision Into Action
Drucker uses a precise set of questions to help convert decisions into actions:

  • Who has to know of this decision?
  • What action has to be taken?
  • Who is to take it?
  • And what does the action have to be so that the people who have to do it can do it?

Drucker wants us that the first and the last of these are too often overlooked – with dire results.

A story to Illustrate the Importance of Who Has to Know
Drucker tells a story that shows us why it's important that the right people know about the decisions:

A story that has become a legend among operations researchers illustrates the importance of the question, Who has to know?  A major manufacturer of industrial equipment decided several years ago to discontinue one model.  For years it had been standard equipment on a line of machine tools, many of which were still in use.  It was decided, therefore, to sell the model to present owners of the old equipment for another three years as a replacement, and then to stop making and selling it.  Orders for this particular model had been going down for a good many years.  But they shot up as former customers recorded against the day when the model would no longer be available.  No one had, however, asked, Who needs to know of this decision?  Therefore, nobody informed the clerk in the purchasing department who was in charge of buying the parts from which the model itself was being assembled.  His instructions were to buy parts in a given ratio to current sales – and the instructions remained unchained.  When the time came to discontinue further production of the model, the company had in its warehouse enough parts for another eight to ten years of production, parts that had to be written off at a considerable loss.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Turn decisions into action commitments.  Actions speak louder than words.  Knowing what to do is not the same as doing what you know.
  • Get the right owners for the actions.
  • Know what the action owners need to be successful and support them.

I see a lot of decisions that never turn into results.  I know people mean well, but making things happen takes more than just desire.  It takes action.  The challenge with turning decisions into action is understanding the work required.

My Related Posts

Sunday, May 11, 2008

3 Interview Questions for Picking the Right People

If you need to interview people, what are the key questions to ask when you're interviewing someone?  In How to Run Successful Projects III: The Silver Bullet (3rd Edition), Fergus O'Connell suggests using three basic questions during the interview to help you evaluate your candidates.

3 Questions to Ask When You Interview
The three questions that O'Connell suggests are:

  • What have you done?
  • What do you want to do?
  • What are you like?

What Have You Done?
The question tells you about the candidates past experience and qualifications.  O'Connell says you can find out more on this by asking:

  • What was the greatest moment of your life?
  • Tell me the three things you've enjoyed doing most in your life?
  • What was your biggest setback?

What Do You Want To Do?
This is the key question.  Ideally you find somebody who is passionate about the work.  O'Connell suggests asking:

  • What do you definitely not want?
  • If you could pick any job in the world what would it be?
  • How would you like your career to go?
  • What drives you?
  • Are you a task-oriented or people-oriented person?
  • What do you do in your leisure time?
  • What would someone else say about you -- a former boss?  It almost doesn't matter who it is -- it's just that if the person is hanging tough on this question, you need to get an answer.
  • How hungry are you for the job?

What are You Like?
This helps you get a feel for their personality.  O'Connell suggests asking:

  • Describe your personality.
  • Are you the kind of person that if I ask you to do a job I can regard it as done?
  • What strengths and weaknesses would you be bringing to the table?
  • Say something negative about yourself.
  • What do you like to read?

Key Take Aways
I know using three questions seems oversimplified but I've used variations of these questions with a lot of success.  Granted you need to know what you're looking for, but these questions definitely help bring out some of the most important aspects of whether somebody is a fit. 

Knowing their past experience can be an indicator of capability and skill level.  Knowing what they want to do can help you understand motivation. Knowing what they are like can help you anticipate whether they'll be a good fit for the team.

At the end of the day, I don't think an interview can replace first-hand experience so ideally you get to try them on the job before you buy, such as in a contract position.

Monday, December 31, 2007

Sequencing to Build Momentum

Who you influence and in what sequence matters. People are heavily influenced by their social networks. Monkey see, monkey do. This can work for or against you. The key is to get the right people on your side. If you're doing a project proposal or pitching an idea, who you pitch it to and in what sequence matters. You can either stack the deck in your favor and build momentum, or you can fight an uphill battle. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about sequencing to build momentum.

Formidable Barrier or Valuable Asset
Influence networks can be barriers or assets. Watkins writes:

"As we have seen, people consistently look to others in their social networks for clues about 'right thinking,' and defer others with expertise or status on particular sets of issues. The resulting influence networks can be a formidable barrier to your efforts or a valuable asset, or both."

Example of Social Influence
Watkins provides an example of social influence showing how a group is persuaded:

"Let us return once more to the example of asking a group of people to do something embarrassing. Suppose that, in response to my request, a respected member of the group said, "No way, I'm doing that. It is disrespectful and foolish." Almost certainly no one else in the group would do what I had asked. But suppose the same person jumped up, grabbed someone else and said, "Let's do it! It'll be fun!" The odds are that everyone else would eventually follow suit. In fact, the last to rise, would feel social pressure to do so: "What's the matter with you?"

Now suppose I did an analysis of the group before this exercise and identified the most respected person. Suppose I met with that person before the exercise and enlisted his or her aid as a confederate to make some important points about group dynamics and social influence. The odds are good that this person would agree to do so - and that others would follow."

Sequencing Strategy
Gain respected allies early on. Watkins writes:

"The fundamental insight is that you can leverage knowledge of influence networks into disproportionate influence on a group with what my colleague Jim Sebenius termed a sequencing strategy. The order in which you approach potential allies and convincables will have a decisive impact on your coalition-building efforts. Why? Once you gain a respected ally, you will typically find it easier to recruit others. As you recruit more allies, your resource base grows. With broader support, the likelihood increases that your agenda will succeed. That optimistic outlook makes it easier to recruit still more supporters.

If you approach the right people first, you can set in motion a virtuous cycle. Therefore you need to decide carefully who you wil approach first, and how you will do it."

Who to Focus On
Watkins suggests focusing on the following first:
  • People with whom you already have supportive relationships.
  • Individuals whose interests are strongly compatible with yours.
  • People who have the critical resources you need to make your agenda succeed.
  • People with important connections who can recruit more supporters.

Key Take Aways
I have several large-scale projects under my belt so I can say with confidence that sequence matters. Here's my key take aways:

  • Build incremental support. Divide and conquer. You don't need to win everybody over at once. In fact, unless it's a sure thing, you probably won't.
  • Tackle your most influential critics first. This serves three purposes. First, it will expose you to some issues you may need to work through. Second, if you get them on your side, it sends a powerful message, helping you get more supporters. Third, it helps mitigate the risk that a powerful critic will derail your momentum downstream. Put it another way, a stitch in time, saves nine.
  • Know when you're not the right person. If you don't have rapport with the people you need on your side, but one of your allies does, see how you can leverage them.
  • Don't get blind-sided by social influence. The best ideas can get shot down, regardless of their merits. It's sad, but true. If you purely focus on the results, but ignore the people mechanics, you can fail. Even if you don't, you can find yourself working harder than you should need to.
  • Consider an exec sponsor. The social influence of the right exec sponsor can carry you over the hurdles, as well as help shape the support all around you.

My Related Posts

Sunday, December 30, 2007

Five Ways to Ensure Commitment and Follow-through

How do you ensure commitment and follow-through for delegated tasks? In Dealing with People You Can't Stand: How to Bring Out the Best in People at Their Worst, Dr. Rick Brinkman and Dr. Rick Kirschner provide five ways for ensuring task completion.

Five Ways to Ensure Commitment and Follow-Through
Brinkman and Kirschner outline five ways managing delegated tasks:

  • Ask for their word of honor. The simplest of these is to ask your Yes person to back the commitment with his or her word of honor. You look them in the eye and say, "Now do I have your word that you'll do that, no matter what?" When people give their word of honor, that's a deeper level of commitment than a simple "Mmhm, or yes."
  • Ask them to summarize the commitment. Have the problem person summarize back to you what will be done, backtracking, and clarifying while letting them give you the details. You say something like, "I wan to make sure you and I both understand how this will be done. Could you describe to me what you will do and when?"
  • Get them to write it down. To help Yes People to remember the commitment, get them to commit in writing, before walking away. Ask them to write down what they plan to do, post a note by the phone, or on the dashboard, give you a copy or put it on the front page of their daily calendar as an affirmation, "I will," and then fill in the commitment they are making. Most
    organized people agree that there is something about the physical act of writing down a commitment that makes it easier to remember and more likely to be acted on.
  • Weird deadlines. "So you will have it on my desk by 10:23 a.m. on Wednesday?" Most people round off time. Weird deadlines are unusual, because they stand out in the mind.
  • Describe negative consequences. The fifth way is to point out the possible negative consequence of not keeping the commitment. Your description of these consequences will be most effective if you put them in terms of people and relationship. "Now let's imagine it is Wednesday at 10:23 and this project you've agreed to do doesn't get done. How is everyone going to feel around here who was depending on you?"

Key Take Aways
I agree with the points above, with some variations. I think managing delegated tasks is part art and part science, and it's largely about understanding the behaviors on your team and in your situation. Here's some techniques I use:

  • "Echo it back to me". This is my technique for checking how well they've internalized the task and how well they understand the work to be done. I used to spend too much time recapping the task, thinking this would help make it stick. I found it's far more effective and efficient to have them echo their understanding back to me, and correct as needed from there. I think this also puts them in the right mindset of owning the task, and making sure they understand it, clarify, push back as necessary or reset expectations.
  • Get input on the estimate. If the people that will do the work, don't have a say, it's a setup for failur. If there's a constraint, ask the person that will do the work, if the work can be done in the time-frame. Find out what can be done in the time-frame or if you need to fix it. Even if you think you know how long it should take, you want buy-in from the person doing the work.
  • Whiteboard it. I ask some folks on the team to write down their tasks, if they have a habit of losing focus or if they have a poor task-management system. If there's no whiteboard, then a piece of paper works fine. I prefer the whiteboard because it's easy to see and update as needed. It also helps build momentum when they list things they got done on their whiteboard. Results are contagious.

My Related Posts

Monday, December 24, 2007

Situational Leadership II

How do you adapt your leadership styles to the task and people at hand? How do you take your leadership game to the next level? In The 3 Keys to Empowerment: Release the Power Within People for Astonishing Results, Ken Blanchard, John P. Carlos, and Alan Randolph propose the Situational Leadership II model. With this model, you apply the appropriate leadership style depending on where your team is for the specific task or goal. For the leadership style, the two key considerations are directive behaviors and supportive behaviors. For the development levels, the two key considerations are competence and commitment.

Situational Leadership II Model
Here's a visual representation of the Situational Leadership II model:



Goal of Situational Leadership II
Blanchard, Carlos, and Randolph write:
"The goal of Situational Leadership II is to provide an environment that permits an individual to move along the development continuum -- through the development cycle -- from Development Level 1 (developing) to Development Level 4 (developed.) The leader uses a leadership style that is appropriate to the individual's development level at each stage of development on a specific goal or task. As the development level changes, the leadership style should change accordingly. There is no best leadership style because development levels vary from person to person and from task to task."

Four Basic Leadership Styles
The four basic leadership styles are:

  • Style 1 - Directing (high directive behavior and low supportive behavior)
  • Style 2 - Coaching (high directive behavior and high supportive behavior)
  • Style 3 - Supporting (high supportive behavior and low directive behavior)
  • Style 4 - Delegating (low supportive behavior and low directive behavior)

Directive behaviors focus on how to do a task. Examples include telling and showing people what to do and when to do it and providing frequent feedback on results. Directive behaviors are key to developing competence in others.

Supportive behaviors focus on developing people's initiative and on their attitudes and feelings toward the task. Good examples of supportive behavior are praising, listening, encouraging and involving others in problem solving and decision making.

Four Development Levels
The four development levels are:

  • Development Level 1 (low competence and high commitment)
  • Development Level 2 (low to some competence and low commitment)
  • Development Level 3 (moderate to high competence and variable commitment)
  • Development Level 4 (high competence and high commitment)

Competence is the knowledge and skills an individual brings to a goal or task. Competence is best determined by demonstrated performance. It can, however, be developed over time with an appropriate direction direction and support.

Commitment is a combination of an individual's motivation and self-confidence on a goal or task. Interest and enthusiasm are exhibited behaviorlly through attentiveness, energy levels, and facial expressions, as well as through verbal cues. Confidence is characterized by a person's self-assuredness. It is the extend to which people trust their own abilities to do a task. If either motivation or confidence is low, commitment as a whole is considered low.

Key Take Aways
I'm a fan of changing the approach based on a situation to improve effectiveness. Here's my key take aways:

  • Identify the appropriate leadership style by identifying the development level for the specific goal or task.
  • Identify the development level by identifying the levels of commitment and competence.
  • Evolve the leadership style as the development level evolves.

My Related Posts

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

Start-ups, Turnarounds, Realignments and Sustaining-Success

In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about the four STARS (start-ups, turnarounds, ralignment, and sustaining-success) situations, challenges, and opportunities.

The Four STARS Situations
Watkins writes about the four STARS situations:

  • Start-up. You are charged with assembling the capabilities (people, funding and technology) to get a new business, product or project off the ground.
  • Turnaround. You take on a unit or group that is recognized to be in trouble and work to get it back on track.
  • Realignment. Your challenge is to revitalize a unit, product, process or project that is drifting into trouble.
  • Sustaining-success. You are shouldering responsibility for preserving the vitality of a successful organization and taking it to the next level.

Start-up
Watkins rights about the challenges and opportunities of the Start-up situation.

Key Challenges:

  • Building Structures and systems from scratch without a clear framework or boundaries.
  • Welding together a cohesive high-performing team.
  • Making do with limited resources.

Key Opportunities:

  • You can do things right from the beginning.
  • People are energized by the possibilities.
  • There is no preexisting rigidity in people’s thinking.

Turnaround
Watkins rights about the challenges and opportunities of the Turnaround situation.

Key Challenges:

  • Reenergizing demoralized employees and other stakeholders.
  • Handling time pressure and having a quick and decisive impact.
  • Going deep enough with painful cuts and difficult personnel choices.

Key Opportunities

  • Everyone recognizes that change is necessary.
  • Affected constituencies (such as suppliers who want the company to stay in business) may offer significant external support.
  • A little success goes a long way.

Realignment
Watkins rights about the challenges and opportunities of the Turnaround situation.

Key Challenges:

  • Dealing with deeply ingrained cultural norms that no longer contribute to high performance.
  • Convincing employees that change is necessary.
  • Restructuring the top team and refocusing the organization.

Key Opportunities

  • The organization has significant pockets of strength.
  • People want to continue to see themselves as successful.

Sustaining Success
Key Challenges:

  • Playing good defense by avoiding decisions that cause problems.
  • Living in the shadow of a revered leader and dealing with the team they created.
  • Finding ways to take the business to the next level.

Key Opportunities

  • A strong team may already be in place.
  • People are motivated to succeed.
  • Foundations for continued success (such as the product pipeline) may be in place.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Identifying which situation you’re in helps you anticipate what to expect.
  • Different situations call for different actions.
  • Having a shared vocabulary for the situations, helps get the team on the same page.

My Related Posts

STARS Model of Business Evolution

You can't figure out where to take a new organization if you do not understand where it has been and how it got to where it is. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about using the STARS model of business evolution for analyzing your business.

The Stars Model
The key point is that businesses (and, for that matter, projects, processes, products, and plans) tend to move predictably from one type of situation to another.





Growth Cycle
Watkins writes:

"Successful start-ups grow and eventually become sustaining-success situations. Often the individuals who managed the start-up move on to tackle new start-ups, and managers more experienced at running larger businesses take over. Theses successful businesses may in turn give birth to internal start-ups as they diversify into new products, services, processes, or technologies. In this way, healthy companies enter a growth cycle."
Recovery Cycle
Watkins writes:
"But entropy increases. Successful businesses tend, because of internal complacency or external challenges or both, to drift toward trouble. Even if the organization is not yet in crisis, acute observers see gathering storm clouds that signal a need for realignment. Realigning an organization usually means redirecting its resources, such as by abandoning aging product lines and developing new technologies. It often means changing the organization's strategy, structure, skills, and even its culture in fundamental ways. Realigning the business returns it to a sustaining-success state, designated in the model as the recovery cycle."
Crisis Cycle
Watkins writes:
"If efforts to realign the business fail, it can end as a full-scale turnaround. This happens when prior leaders failed to see the need for realignment. (After all, businesses rarely go directly from sustaining success to turnaround.) No matter why this happened, there is rarely argument about the need to make big changes fast, if the situation is dire, the business is losing money, and its best talent is jumping ship. Turning around a failing business requires the new leader to cut it down to a defendable core fast and then begin to build it back up. This painful process, if successful, leaves the business in a sustaining success situation, as illustrated by the crisis cycle. If efforts to turn around the business fail, the result is shutdown or divestiture."

Key Take Aways
Here’s my key take aways:

  • Know the three cycles: Growth Cycle, Recovery Cycle, and Crisis Cycle.
  • Know the four situations: Start-up, Turnaround, Realignment, and Sustaining-success.
  • Use this model to figure out the history of your business and where to take it.

Sunday, December 2, 2007

The Fatal Assumption

In The E-Myth Revisited: Why Most Small Businesses Don't Work and What to Do About It, Michael E. Gerber, writes about how a technician starting a small business can make a fatal assumption.

The Fatal Assumption
Gerber writes:

"That Fatal Assumption is: if you understand the technical work of a business, you understand a business that does that technical work.

And the reason it's fatal is that is just isn't true. In fact, it's the root cause of most small business failures!

The technical work of a business and a business that does that technical work are two totally different things!"
A Place to Go to Work
Gerber writes:
"But the technican who starts a business fails to see this. To the technician suffering from an Enterpreneurial Seizure, a business is not a business but a place to go to work.

So the carpenter, or the electrician, or the plumber becomes a contractor. The barber opens up a barber shop. The technical writer starts a technical writing business. The hairdresser starts a beauty salon. The engineer goes into the semiconductor business. The musician opens up a music store.

All of them believing that by understanding the technical work of the business they are immediately and eminently qualified to run a business that does that kind of work. And it's simply not true!"
Greatest Single Asset or Greatest Liability?
Gerber writes:
"In fact, rather than being their greatest single asset, knowing the technical work of their business becomes their greatest liability.

For if the technician didn't know how to do the technical work of the business, he would have to learn how to get it done. He would be forced to learn how to make the business work, rather than do the work himself."
The Technician's Nightmare
Gerber writes:
"The real tragedy is that when the technician falls prey to the Fatal Assumption, the business that was supposed to free him from the limitations of working for somebody else actually enslaves him.

Suddenly the job he knew how to do so well becomes one job he knows how to do plus a dozen others he doesn't khnow how to do at all. Because although the Entrepreneurial Seizure started the business, it's the technician who goes to work.
And suddenly, an entrepreneurial dream turns into a technician's nightmare."

My Related Posts

The Entrepreneur, The Manager, and The Technician

In The E-Myth Revisited: Why Most Small Businesses Don't Work and What to Do About It, Michael E. Gerber, writes about how The Entrepreneur, The Manager and The Technician are competing personalities inside us all.

The Entrepreneur
Gerber writes about The Entrepreneur:

"The entrepreneur personality turns the most trival condition into an exceptional opportunity. The Entrepreneur is the visionary in us. The dreamer. The energy behind every human activity. The imagination that sparks the fire of the future. The catalyst for change.

The way he usually chooses is to bully harass, excoriate, flatter, cajole, scream, and finally, when all else fails, promise whatever he must to keep the project moving."
The Manager
Gerber writes about The Manager:
"The managerial personality is pragmattic. Without The Manager there would be no planning, no order, no predictability.

If the Entrepreneur lives in the future, The Manager lives in the past. Where The Enterpreneur craves control, The Manager craves order. Where The Entrepreneur thrives on change, The Manager compulsively clings to the status quo. Where The Entrepreneur invariably sees the opportunity in events, The Manager invariably sees the problems.

The Manager is the one who runs after the Entrepreneur to clean up the mess. Without The Entrepreneur there would be no mess to clean up. without The Manager, there could be no business, no society. Without The Enterpreneur, there would be no innovation.

Is is the tension between The Entrepreneur's vision and The Manager's pragmatism that creates the synthesis from which all great works are born."
The Technician
Gerber writes about The Technician:
"The Technician is the doer. "If you want it done right, do it yourself" is The Technician's credo.

The Technician loves to tinker. Things are to be taken apart and put back together again. Things aren't supposed to be dreamed about, they're supposed to be done.

If the Entrepreneur lives in the future and The Manager lives in the past, The Technician lives in the present. He loves the feel of things and the fact that things can get done.

As long as the Technician is working, he is happy, but only on one thing at a time. He knows that tow things can't get done simultaneously; only a fool would try. So he works steadily and is happiest when he is in control of the work flow.

The Technician knows that if it weren't for him, the world would be in more trouble than it already is. Nothing would get done, but lots of people would be thinking about it. Put it another way, while the Enterpreneur dreams, The Manager frets, and the Technician ruminates."
Everybody Gets in the Technician's Way
Gerber writes how everybody gets in the way of The Technician:
"Everyone gets in The Technician's way. The Entrepreneur is always throwing a monkey wrench into his day with the creation of yet another "great new idea."

On the other hand, The Entrepreneur is always creating new and interesting work for The Technician to do, thus establishing a potentially symbiotic relationship.

Unfortunately, it rately works out that way. Since most enterpreneurial ideas don't work in the real world, The Technician's usual experience is one of frustration and annoyance at being interrupted in the course of doing what needs to be done to try something new that probably doesn't need to be done at all."
The System
Gerber writes about the tension between "the person" and "the system":
"The Manager is also a problem to The Technician because hs is determined to impose order on The Technician's work, to reduce him to a part of "the system."

But being a rugged individualist, The Technician can't stand being treated that way. To The Technician, "the system" is dehumanizing, cold, antiseptic, and impersonal. It violates his individuality. Work is what a person does. And to the degree that it's not, work becomes something foreign.

To The Manager, then, The Technician becomes a problem to be managed. To The Technician, The Manager comes a mddler to be avoided. To both of them, The Entrepreneur is the one who got them into trouble in the first place."
The Entrepreneur, The Manager and The Technician Inside Us All
Gerber writes about how we have all three inside us:
"The fact of the matter is that we all have an Entrepreneur, Manager and Technician inside us. And if they were equally balanced, we'd be describing an incredibly competent indvidual.

The Entrepreneur would be free to forge ahead into new areas of interest; The Manager would be solidifying the base of operations; and The Technician would be doing the technical work.

Each would derive satisfaction from the work he does best, serving the whole in the most productive way."

Key Take Aways
What a great way to explain the tension, whether inside us or where we work! Here's my key take aways:

  • Know the competing personalities. Sometimes knowing is half the battle. In this case, I think being able to recognize the different personalities is a big first step.
  • Balance is the key. I like how Gerber illustrates the importance of balance among the personalities. He shows how each personality fullfills an important part of the bigger picture. Leverage comes from the synegery, not the dominance. It raises the important question: are you balancing The Entrepreneur, The Manager, and The Technician inside you?

My Related Posts

Sunday, August 5, 2007

Vision, Mission, and Values

Your mission, vision and values are the foundation for your company's success. It's how you communicate your unique value, set goals and priorities, and create a compelling future. It's ultimately your gauge for success (are you accomplishing your mission and moving towards your vision?)  In A Simple Statement: A Guide to Nonprofit Arts Management and Leadership, Jamie Grady writes about vision, mission, and values.

Creating Your Mission and Vision
The key steps to creating your mission and vision are:

  • Identify the values of the organization. You find these by observing how employees spend their time, how they set priorities and how they allocate their time and energy. Actions are more revealing than words.
  • Create the mission statement. The mission answers "who are you?" It should consist of one or two sentences max. It should quickly communicate the company's purpose. It should be an original and unique purpose. It should encapsulate the philosophy, beliefs, values and principles. It should be unique, exciting and inspiring. It sets the foundation for priorities, strategies, plans, and work assignments. The company should derive strength from the mission rather than react to outside influences.
  • Create the vision. The vision statement answers, "where do you want to go?"
Example Mission and Vision
Grady provides an example of using a vision statement and mission statement to communicate the philosophical foundation of an arts organization to its stakeholders:

Court Theatre - Strategic Plan

  • Mission - Court Theatre exists to celebrate the immutable power and relevance of classic theatre.
  • Vision - We share a collective aspiration to create a National Center for Classic Theatre.

Example Values
Grady provides an example statement of values:

Strategic Decisions Are Guided by the Following Statement of Values

  • We believe theatre satisfies an innate human need for communal acts of
    imagining.
  • We believe works for the stage that reveal timeless themes and illuminate
    universal truths are classics.
  • We believe in the primacy of language in theatre.
  • We believe in an artistic process that is venturous, collaborative, grounded
    in thorough research and dynaically evolving.
  • We believe in an artistic process that is venturous, collaborative, grounded
    in thorough research and dynamically evolving.
  • We believe in an environment of trust, generosity, and shared vision enables
    risk-taking in the artistic process.
  • We believe the artistic process should inform all aspects of the threatre's
    operations including leadership, governance, and administration.
  • We believe classic theatre is a valid participant in American culture, its
    survival and maturation.
  • We believe artists make significant contributions to their communities.
  • We believe learning is a life-long journey, and classic theatre has a unique
    ability to teach and inspire its creators and patrons.
  • We believe in freedom of expression, and embrace a plethora of artistic
    voices and styles.
  • We believe in diversity across all definitions.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Use  a vision statement, mission statement and statement of values to communicate the foundation of your group to stakeholders.
  • The mission statement answers who are you.
  • The vision statement is where you want to go, once you know who you are.
  • Figure out the real values by actually observing the group.  This is more accurate than just thinking them up.  Otherwise, people say one thing, but do another.

Additional Resources

My Related Posts

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

Measure of Success

In A Simple Statement: A Guide to Nonprofit Arts Management and Leadership, Jamie Grady writes about measuring success.

Measure Success Against the Mission and Vision
Grady writes about how the mission and vision guide success:

For a nonprofit organization, making a profit is not necessarily the definitive measure of success, nor is an increased budget size or staff. The evaluation of success lies in the mission and vision statements and is particular to that organization. Success may represent an increase in audience, in the number of people served by a particular program, or in artistic quality. Success is also measured by the progress the company has made in fulfilling its vision. Success is measured in the short term by the accomplishments of goals and objectives and how those accomplishments have moved the organization closer to its vision.

Vision is an Image of Success
Grady writes how the vision is an image of success:

Vision statements give the organization and its employees an image of success. Without the need to succeed, people and organizations would never reach their full potential. Reaching the company's full potential is what a vision statement is all about.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:
  • Measure your success against your mission and vision. Use progress against your vision as a yardstick to measure success.
  • Your vision is an image of success. This is a reminder that your success, begins with the vision.

My Related Posts

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Eight Rules of businessThink

How do you make more effective strategic business decisions?  How can you build more effective business cases?  How can you more effectively analyze business decisions?  How do you figure out what the impact of your decisions will be?  In businessThink: Rules for Getting It Right--Now, and No Matter What!, Dave Marcum, Steve Smith, and Mahan Khalsa have eight rules for more effectively building and analyzing business cases.

The Eight Rules of businessThink
According to Marcum, Smith, and Khalsa, the eight rules of businessThink are:

  • Rule 1: Check Your Ego at the Door. Check your ego at the door. Work delicately with the egos of others to keep dialogue open. Change yourself to lead to a change in the business.
  • Rule 2: Create Curiosity. Ask questions and gather perspectives from your company's collective intellectual diversity.3.
  • Rule 3: Move Off the Solution. Get to the underlying business issues. Make sure you're not guessing. Focus your attention on the vital few issues.
  • Rule 4: Get Evidence. Collect the soft evidence to prove that the business problem or opportunity exists. Turn the soft evidence into hard evidence that the business can measure.
  • Rule 5: Calculate the Impact. Convert the hard evidence into a financial equivalent to make sure that there is a worthwhile impact or payoff.
  • Rule 6: Explore the Ripple Effect. Carefully consider who or what else in the company is affected by the problem or opportunity. Consider the relative weight of the importance of the issue compared to other intitiatives in the company.
  • Rule 7: Slow Down for Yellow Lights. Know what has stopped the company from successfully doing something about this before now, or what might stop you in the future. If the impact of a problem or opportunit is big, ask "What has stopped you (or the company as a whole) from successfully resolving these issues before now?" If this is a new opportunity with no history, the yellow-light question is "What, if anything, might prevent the successful implementation of this solution from going forward?"
  • Rule 8: Find the Cause. Identify the cause producing the symptoms that are showing up. Treat the cause of the problem rather than the effects.

Why businessThink ?
The authors claims that applying businessThink will help you:

  • Make winning strategic business decisions.
  • Have colleagues trust your judgement and leadership.
  • Leverage and utilize your talents.
  • Become highly influential and relevant.
  • Create business value.

Key Take Aways
What I like about businessThink is that it's a distillation of what the authors have put into practice. What I also like about the approach is that it's something you can put into practice yourself (i.e. I don't have any bottlenecks to start using businessThink on the job). The more I apply it, the better I'll get.

I think creating compelling business cases is a key to effectiveness. Whether you're competing for resources, time, and budget, or simply trying to convince others that your idea has merit, the business case is key. I see some of the best ideas never get put into action because the owner never created a compelling business case. If there's one skill to master for today's competitive landscape, I think it's creating business cases and businessThink is the tool to help you do it.

My Related Posts

Sunday, July 1, 2007

Calculating Impact

In businessThink: Rules for Getting It Right--Now, and No Matter What!, the Dave Marcum, Steve Smith, and Mahan Khalsa use five questions to convert hard evidence into impact.

The Five Golden Questions
According to Marcum, Smith, and Khalsa, you can use the following five golden questions to convert evidence into impact:

  • How do you measure it?
  • What is it now?
  • What would you like it to be?
  • What's the value of the difference?
  • What's the value of the difference over time (months, years -- the appropriate management horizon)?

Key Take Aways
At work, I tend to ask the questions, "how big is the pie?" and "how big is our slice?" While they're a start, I think The Five Golden Questions above help add dimension and depth when you're trying to understand and articulate potential impact.

Monday, June 18, 2007

Planning a Mission

In the book Flawless Execution: Use the Techniques and Systems of America's Fighter Pilots to Perform at Your Peak and Win the Battles of the Business World, James D. Murphy shares a six-step process for mission planning.

The Six Steps to Mission Planning

  • Step 1. Determine the Mission Objective. A mission objective has to be clear, measurable, and believable.
  • Step 2. Identify the Threats. In this step, you identify your internal and external threats.
  • Step 3. Identify Your Available Resources. This includes people, money, systems, technologies, products, clients, time, known strengths, services or skills of the team that negate your threats or help you accomplish your objective.
  • Step 4. Evaluate the Lessons Learned. This step is where you use the experiences of someone who's been there before.
  • Step 5. Determine Courses of Action/Tactics. This step is where you develop menus of possible courses of action. This is where you develop a timeline, including who does what when. This is where you develop a decision matrix. This is also where you take your plan apart and attempt to defeat it.
  • Step 6. Plan for Contingencies. This is where you create detailed scripted responses for possible events.

Key Take Aways
Personally, I find this approach very consistent with how I perform my missions at work. I always start by clarifying what we want to accomplish in terms of objectives and outcomes. Knowing what can go wrong and having fallback positions is a key to success. Leveraging past experience helps avoid or repeast past mistakes. I play out a few possible courses and look for the best fit within the criteria. Probably the biggest distinction with the approach above is that I tend to use a constraint-driven model, particularly using time, and then figuring out how to deliver value within that time.

My Related Posts

Monday, June 11, 2007

Sharing Lessons Learned

In the book, Flawless Execution: Use the Techniques and Systems of America's Fighter Pilots to Perform at Your Peak and Win the Battles of the Business World, James D. Murphy shares a particularly colorful story to illustrate the importance of sharing lessons learned:

"Let's go back in history. In Vietnam, if a fighter pilot could survive his first ten missions, there was a good chance he would survive 100 missions and go home to his family. But the first ten missions were tough -- most of the pilots lost were lost inside of ten missions. To survive long enough to go home, a pilot first had to get through those initial ten missions."
What I think this example highlights is that you put a premium on transferring knowledge when the stakes are high and you see the immediate impact. Unfortunately, I think in many business scenarios, the feedback loops are too long and the impact isn't so obvious.

My Related Posts

STEALTH Debrief

In, Flawless Execution: Use the Techniques and Systems of America's Fighter Pilots to Perform at Your Peak and Win the Battles of the Business World,James D. Murphy shares a 7 step process for continuous learning and improvement:

The Stealth Debrief
  • S. Set time / location / preparation. Let everyone know what they need to bring to the debrief. Start and end on time. Don't let the debrief degrade into an endless postmortem. Another key is identifying objectives, such as what future actions are desired. Will you do things better? Will you pass along the good stuff to othes? Are you changing future plans and/or strategy
  • T. Tone (Nameless, rankless, open communication; lead by example) In this step, you do an inside outside criticism. You criticize yourself first (inside) and then to tyour team for criticism (outside). You start by listing your mistakes. When you talk about the team mistakes you observed, you keep it nameless by using third person (you substitute roles orp ositions, for example, the wingman, the architect, the developer ... etc.)
  • E. Execution versus objectives. In this step, you ask the question, how well did you execute based on what you said you were doing to do? That's it. How well did you do. Focus on results rather than objectives. What did you get done, what did you not get done? ... If you did not get it done, why?
  • A. Analyze execution. Here you determine the underlying causes of problems or issues. Look for the root cause.
  • L. Lessons learned. In this step, find the prominent or recurring root cause that bridges together several errors or successes. A lesson learned comes out of a pattern of recurring root causes. Lessons learned are systemtic issues.
  • T. Transfer lessons learned throughout your organization. In this step, you tell people what you've learned. The specific fix you recommend needs to be clearly written so that others within your organization can understand the issue and benefit from the solution even if they were not there.
  • H. High note - positive summation. End the debrief on a high note. After dissecting a mission, admitting errors, and underscoring successes, you have to end the debrief with something positive.

James summarizes the benefits of using STEALTH debriefs:


"The goal of an effective debrief is to generate valuable lessons learned, then to institutionalize those lessons learned into a core of best business practices. Once that is done, the lessons learned are transferred throughout the company. What does this accomplish? 1. Learning is accelerated, which is a process. 2. Experience is increased, which is an asset. These two combine to improve future execution, which, as we know, affects the bottom line. ... That's the power of the debrief. It identifies problems (or opportunities) and accelerates the spread of the resulting solutions."

Key Take Aways

  • I'm very much a fan of sharing lessons learned, finding root causes, and focusing on my mistakes first (since I own them, I can fix myself first), so this approach resonates with me.
  • I like the crispness of the inward outward criticism. Starting with yourself keeps accountability and encourages reflection.
  • I like the nameless perspective by using third person. I find this helps stay focused on improving the role, technique or process versus pointing fingers at individuals. It's also easier to carry the lessons forward, since it's abstracted from the particular individual.

Saturday, June 9, 2007

How To Paint a Future Picture

How do you paint a clear, high-resolution, and easily communicated big picture of how you want the future to be? Use 12 key descriptors to create a detailed picture. In Flawless Execution: Use the Techniques and Systems of America's Fighter Pilots to Perform at Your Peak and Win the Battles of the Business World, James D. Murphey writes about how to paint a clear picture that you can communicate up and down the stack.

12-Point Future Picture
Murphey outlines the 12 points that clarify a future picture:

  • Financial Position. Describe your company's financial position as you would like to be in a reasonable amount of time, say three to five years. Will you measure internal rate of return (IRR), earnings, revenue, EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization0, or what?
  • Market Position. Describe your market position. Will you be a leader or a follower? Are you a fringe segment? Elaborate.
  • Business Areas. What business(es) do you intend to be in?
  • Innovation. Will you innovate or use off-the-shelf technology? Is R&D part of your future?
  • Insider Perception. What is the insider view of the company? How do the various stakeholders view the company? Is it a good place to work, a good investment? Elaborate.
  • Outsider Perception. What should the outsider perception be? A growing company, profitable, customer-oriented? Professional, competent?
  • Workforce Characteristics. What are the features of your workforce? What are their skills, special talents?
  • Brand: Yes or No. Are you going to have a branded product or a commodity product? Will you be an OEM (original equipment manufacturer) to another company?
  • Corporate Culture. What is your vision of your corporate culture? Are you entrepreneurial with a minimum of bureaucratic layers? Are you productivity driven like Dell Computer?
  • Corporate citizenship. What is your vision of corporate citizenship? Will you make a contribution to the quality of life in your communities? Why?
  • Ownership. Will your company be public, private, or have an employee stock plan?
  • Incentive Philosophy. What will your incentive plans be based on? Straight pay, shared risk, rewards based on results?

Key Take Aways
Well, that's certainly high-resolution! When I need to share a vision with others, I do a quick self-check against this list. While I usually don't have all the answers, it does give me a map of where I need to get more clarity.

Saturday, May 26, 2007

Satisficing to Get Things Done

In Sources of Power: How People Make Decisions, Gary Klein writes:

The difference between singular and comparitive evaluation is linked to the research of Herbert Simon, who won a Nobel Prize for economics. Simon (1957) identified a decision strategy he calls satisficing: Selecting the first option that works. Satisficing is different from optimizion, which means trying to come up with the best strategy. Optimizing is hard and it takes a long time. Satisficing is more efficient. The singular evaluation strategy is based on satisficing. Simon used the concept of satisficing to describe the decision behavior of businesspeople.

The key here is that satisficing means figuring out what a satisfactory outcome would be and then finding ways to achieve it.

Gary goes on to point out that this is how experienced fireground commanders can quickly make effective decisions under extreme time pressure. Rather than explore all possible options and evaluate their trade-offs, they quickly run a mental simulation in their mind. If they find the option won't work, they move on to the next.

The key here is "experienced" fireground commanders. Novices need to evaluate options and their trade-offs to make effective decisions, which is a much more time consuming process.

Key Take Aways

  1. Experts avoid optimizing a single value -- they look for a best fit against a set of criteria, and take the first fit against that (very quickly in their head).
  2. Novices don’t have this option because they don’t know the options, don’t know the important criteria, and don’t have the benefit of experience to evaluate against.

Additional Resources