Showing posts with label Leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Leadership. Show all posts

Sunday, May 25, 2008

Choose "How" Questions Over "Why" Questions

Why are you stuck?  That's not a very empowering question.  You'll just figure out reasons for why you're stuck.  Instead, ask a question like "how can you move forward?" or "how might you accomplish that?"  The key is to ask "how" questions over "why" questions.  In Unlimited Power : The New Science Of Personal Achievement, Tony Robbins writes about choosing "how" questions over "why" questions.

Choose "How" Questions Over "Why" Questions
Robbins writes that you should choose "how" questions over "why" questions:

Here's another important frame.  Choose "how" questions over "why" questions.  "Why" questions can get you reasons and explanations and justifications and excuses.  But they usually don't come up with useful information.  Don't ask your kid why he is having trouble with algebra.  Ask him what he needs to do to perform better.  There's no need to ask an employee why he didn't get a contract you were bidding for.  Ask him how he can change so you'll be certain to get the next one. 

Good Communicators Move Forward
Robbins writes that good communicators focus on moving forward over rationalizing why something's wrong:

Good communicators aren't interested in rationalizations of why something is going wrong.  They want to find out how to do it right.  The right questions will lead you in that direction.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Choose "how" questions over "why" questions.
  • Don't dwell on what's wrong, focus on what's right.
  • Find a way to move forward.

My Related Posts

Friday, May 16, 2008

First Know What's Right for Effective Decision Making

To make effective decisions, first figure out what would be the right thing to do.  That's your starting point.  There's a good chance you'll have to compromise along the way, but first figure out what the right solution would be before you start trimming it down.  You can't make the right compromises if you don't first know what right is.  In The Essential Drucker: The Best of Sixty Years of Peter Drucker's Essential Writings on Management, Peter Drucker writes about starting with what's right to avoid giving away what's important during negotiation.

What’s Right Over What’s Acceptable for Effective Decision Making
Drucker reminds us that everybody can make compromises, but they need to start from what's right, not what's acceptable:

One has to start out with what is right rather than what is acceptable (let alone who is right) precisely because one always has to compromise in the end.  But if one does not know what is right to satisfy the specifications and boundary conditions, one cannot distinguish between the right compromise and the wrong compromise – and will end up by making the wrong compromise.

First Know What Right Is
Drucker shares a story to make the point that it's your job to figure out what's right before you start compromising:

I was taught this when I started in 1944 on my first big consulting assignment, as study of the management structure and management policies of General Motors Corporation.  Alfred P. Sloan Jr., who was then chairman and chief executive officer of the company, called me to his office at the start of my study and said, “I shall not tell you what to study, what to write, or what conclusions to come to.  This is your task.  My only instruction to you is to put down what you think is right as you see it.  Don’t worry about our reaction.  Don’t you worry about whether we will like this or dislike that.  And don’t you, above all, concern yourself with compromises that might be needed to make your recommendations acceptable.  There is not one executive in the company who does not know how to make every single conceivable compromise without any help from you.   But he can’t make the right compromise unless you first tell him what ‘right’ is.”  The executive thinking through a decision might put this in front of himself in neon light.

If You Start Out With What’s Acceptable, You Give Away What’s Important
Drucker makes the point that if you start off with what's acceptable, you'll end up giving away what's really important:

It is fruitless and a waste of time to worry about what is acceptable and what one had better not say so as not to evoke resistance.  The things one worries about never happen.  And objections and difficulties no one thought about suddenly turn out to be almost insurmountable obstacles.  One gains nothing, in other words, by starting out with the question.  One gains nothing, in other words, by starting out with the question, What is acceptable?  And in the process of answering it, one gives away the important things, as a rule, and loses any chance to come up with an effective, let alone with the right, answer.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • To make the right compromise, first know what right is.
  • To figure out what's right, don’t worry about our reaction, don’t you worry about whether the decision will be liked, and don’t concern yourself with compromises that might be needed to make your recommendations acceptable.
  • If you have a baseline for what right is, then you can make more effective compromises.

My Related Posts

Saturday, April 26, 2008

How to Consistently Build a Winning Team

How do you build a winning team? I think successful coaches are good to learn from. In Social Psychology: Theories, Research, and Applications, Robert S. Feldman interviews Joe Paterno, head coach of Pennsylvania State University's college football team. In the interview, Feldman asks Coach "JoePa" about his secrets for building winning teams and group cohesiveness.

Build Some Pride in Being Part of the Team
The team has to be special. Feldman asks Coach Joe about how he molds individuals into a winning team:

  • Q. "Many coaches work with players as talented as yours, yet don't win as many games ... what's your secret of success?"
  • A. "... I think it begins with the way you put your program together. You have to immediately build up some price in being part of the organization. We talk all the time about not being afraid of being different, being unique. We demand more of people, from the time when we first begin recruiting ... You may have noticed we don't have anything on our uniforms; they're very plain -- no stripes, no names, nothing on the helmets. We wear black shoes ... There is a purpose for that. When our players put their uniforms on we want them to understand that they are part of a first-rate football team. Although they may not be better than other football players, they're different, they're unique -- not because of their individual strengths, but because they are part of a special Penn State team ... I build up a background in practice. We practice better than anybody; we practice harder than anybody; and we probably have higher pride than anybody. All this serves to create a kind of mystique about the situation which means that when they go out and play, there's more at stake than just football. It's the individual's pride and the commitment that he's made to the team."

The Effects of the Team Go Beyond Team Activities
According to Coach Joe, the effects go beyond the team:

  • Q. "Then there are effects of being on the team that go beyond the football field?"
  • A. "Absolutely. In the dormitories for instance, I want the dorm counselor to be able to count on the players because they're part of the team."

Build Successors
Coach Joe says it's not just about him; he develops leadership within the team:

  • Q. "I would guess that after being part of the team for a while, the football players would begin to internalize these standards themselves. It's not just a matter of doing what you say, is it?"
  • A. "Not at all. I try to develop leadership in the seniors and upperclassmen. They keep an eye on their teammates. I tell them they've got to be proud of the football team, and proud of their teammates."

Appear to Be Fair
Coach Joe says it's not about playing favorites:

  • Q. "Is there a lot of competition within the team regarding, let's say, who's going to start."
  • A. "A tremendous amount. I think it's one of the things that is most difficult in coaching. When it comes down to a youngster who really wants to play and feels that he's really good, then you have a problem. I don't know exactly how to solve it except to try to lean over backward to be fair to everybody. And I have a rule as a coach that it's not enough to be fair, you must appear to be fair. I think if you can get an individual to think that you really are concerned, you've got a chance to keep that youngster motivated. But it's a tough job."

Team Players Over Individual Results
Coach Joe emphasizes team results over individuals:

  • Q. "Do you ever have a problem getting especially talented players -- the "stars" -- to cooperate with the team?"
  • A. "Well, I have little sympathy for those people who don't. The best players have the most to gain by being cooperative. Football is so much a game of dependency. No matter how good you are, there are a lot of other people you're going to depend on."

Understand Each Individual
Coach Joe says it's their team, not his:

  • Q. "How do you maintain morale -- group cohesiveness, a social psychologist would call it -- consistently?"
  • A. "You can't create morale overnight, and once you have it's not easy to maintain but it's something you've got to work at all the time. You've got a bunch of guys involved in a program who have got to feel responsible for each other. But we also try to understand each one of them as an individual, with individual problems, and all those kinds of things. Finally, we make a point of being concerned about his morale and spend time to make sure he is trated fairly. I think it's important for every member of the team to feel it's their team. It's no my team; it's their team."

Key Take Aways
I think Coach Joe applies a lot of the principles I've seen work in practice. Here's my key take aways:

  • Build pride in the team. There's a big difference between being on a team you're proud to be on and a team you're embarrassed by. Joining a team that's great to be on, can help set the tone ad pace that brings out everybody's best.
  • Appear to be fair. I think this is especially important. I've been on team's where where everybody has a shot. I've also seen the opposite. There's a big difference between putting the best player in a position versus playing favorites. Who continues to give their best, when the best it trumped by favoritism?
  • Build successors. I'm a fan of growing others and learning in the process. I think on a team in today's world this is particularly important. If you're the bottleneck for everything that gets done, then you put a glass ceiling on yourself and on the team. I always try to work myself out of a job, by teaching others and improving the job itself.
  • Beware of ball hogs. A ball hog can really get in the way of an effective team. There's a big difference between doing your best at the expense of the team, and doing your best with the team.
  • Understand each individual. At the end of the day, a team is a group of individuals. Appreciate the individuals for how they are.

My Related Posts

Monday, March 10, 2008

Identify Supporters, Opponents and Convincibles

How do you identify your supporters, opponents and convincibles?  Part of putting your ideas in place, means knowing the influence map.  You need to know your supporters and opponents as well as those that you can convince to join your efforts.  In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about identifying your supporters, opponents, and convincibles.  

Supporters
Supporters will approve your agenda because it advances their own interests, because they respect you, or because they see merit in your ideas.  Watkins provides examples:

  • People who share your vision for the future.  If you see a need for going through change, look for others who have pushed for changes like those you are promoting.
  • People who have been quietly working for change on a small scale, such as a plant engineer who has found an innovative way to significantly reduce waste.
  • People new to the company who have not yet become acculturated to its mode of operations.

Opponents
Opponents will oppose you not matter what you do.  They may believe that you are wrong or they may have other reasons for resistance to your agenda.  Watkins provides examples:

  • Comfort with the status quo.  They resist changes that might undermine their position or alter established relationships.
  • Fear of looking incompetent.  They fear seeming or feeling incompetent if they have trouble adapting to the changes you are proposing and perform inadequately afterward.
  • Threat to values.  They believe you ar promoting a culture that spurns traditional definitions of value or rewards inappropriate behavior.
  • Threat to power.  They fear that the change you are proposing (such as a shift from team-leader decision making to team consensus decision making) would deprive them of power.
  • Negative consequences for key allies.  They fear that your agenda will have negative consequences for others they care about or feel responsible for.

Convincibles
Watkins writes:

"Convincibles are the swing voters:  people who are undecided about or indifferent to change, and people you think you could persuade once you understand and appeal to their interests.  Once you have identified convincibles look into what motivates them.  People are motivated by different things, such as status, financial security or wealth, job security, positive social and professional relationships with colleagues, and opportunities to tackle new and stimulating challenges.  So take the time to figure out what they perceive their interests to be.  Start by putting yourself in their shoes:  If you were them, what would you care about?  If it is possible to engage them directly in dialogue, then ask questions about how they see the situation, and engage in active active listening.  If you have connections to other people in their organization, then you should use them to learn.  If you don't, you might think about judiciously cultivating them.

Meanwhile, ask yourself whether there are competing forces that might tip convincibles toward resisting you.  For example, making them see that their interests are compatible with yours would prompt them to support you, but the threat of losing a comfortable status quo might trigger resistance.  Interests and competing forces should be part of what you undertake to learn about the politics of your organization through conversations, exploration of past decisions, and observation of group interactions."

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Explicitly map out your supporters, opponents and convincibles.
  • Know the key reasons for resistance by your opponents.  You may be able to address the resistance and turn opponents into supporters.
  • Get convincibles on your side by knowing their motivation.

My Related Posts

Sunday, March 9, 2008

Assessing Your Existing Team

What are the most important attributes of the people on your team?  Which attributes can you influence or change versus which are relatively fixed?   What is your threshold value for whether somebody should be on your team?  In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about using key criteria to evaluate your team.

Six Criteria for Assessing People on Your Team
Watkins identifies six criteria for assessing individuals on your team:

  • Competence.  Does this person have the technical competence and experience to do the job effectively?
  • Judgement.  Does this person exercise good judgement, especially under pressure when faced with making sacrifices for the greater good.
  • Energy.  Does this team member bring the right kind of energy to do the job, or is he or she burned out or disengaged?
  • Focus.  Is this person capable of setting priorities and sticking to them, or prone to "riding off in all directions"?
  • Relationships.  Does this individual get along with others on the team and support collective decisions making, or is he or she difficult to work with?
  • Trust.  Can you trust this person to keep his or her word and follow through on commitments?

Fill Out a Table
Watkins writes:

"To get a quick read on the criteria you use, fill out a table.  Allow yourself 100 points to divide among the six criteria according to the relative weight you place on them when you evaluate direct reports.  Record those numbers in the middle column, making sure that they add up to 100.  Now identify one of those criteria as your 'threshold issue.' meaning that if a person does not meet a basic threshold on that dimension, nothing else matters.  Label your threshold issue with an asterisk in the right-hand column."

Example Table
Watkins provides an example table:

Evaluative Criteria Relative Weights (Divide 100 points among the six issues) Threshold Issue (Designate with an asterisk)
Competence - -
Judgment - -
Energy - -
Focus - -
Relationships - -
Trust - -

Analyze Your Results
Watkins writes:

"Now step back.  Does this accurately represent the values you apply when you evaluate direct reports?  If so, does this analysis suggest any potential blind spots in the way you evaluate people?

Your assessments are likely to reflect certain assumptions about what you can and can't change in people who work for you.  If you score relationships low and judgment high, for example, you may think that relationships within your team are something you can influence, whereas you cannot influence judgment.  Likewise, you may have designated trust as a threshold issue -- many leaders do -- because you believe that you must be able to trust those who work for you and because you think trustworthiness is a trait that cannot be changed."

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Identify your criteria.  Your criteria should support your success.  This means both having people you can count on to do their jobs as well as complimenting your ability.
  • Find your blind spots.  It might be a blind spot for you if you think you can change attributes that you really can't or that are ineffective.  You also might be undervaluing certain attributes.  Use the table to reflect on how well the results match your experience.
  • Identify what you think you can change and what you can't.  While it's true that you can influence behavior, changing some attributes just might not be worth it.

My Related Posts

Overcoming Resistance with Entanglement Strategies

How do you overcome resistance to change in your organization? You can move people in a series of small steps. Incremental buy-in over time can often be more effective than trying to change too much at once, particularly if you face a lot of resistance. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about using entanglement strategies to overcome resistance to change in your organization.

Reformulating Incentives, Framing Arguments and Action-Forcing Events
Watkins writes:


"Reformulating incentives, framing arguments, and setting up action-forcing events are relatively static persuasion techniques. You figure out how people perceive their choices, and then you craft a mix of push and pull forces that alter those perceptions. Voila, you get the behavior you want."

Adopt Entanglement Strategies
Watkins writes:


"But what if moving people from where they are (comfortable with the status quo) is either impossible to achieve all at once or just too expensive for you? What do you do then?

You could adopt entanglement strategies that move people from A to B in a series of small steps rather than a single leap. To return to the example of including a group to do something embarrassing, I could start by asking them to stand up. Then I could ask them to stand on one foot, and so on. "

Leverage Small Commitments Into Larger Ones
Watkins writes:


"One approach is to leverage small commitments into larger ones. If you are trying to launch a new initiative, begin by getting people to agree to participate in an initial organizing meeting. Then get them to commit to a subsequent meeting, then to doing a small piece of analysis, and so on. Entanglement works because each step creates a new psychological reference point for deciding whether to take the next small step. When possible, try to make each step irreversible, like a door that locks once it has been passed through. Getting people to make commitments in public, for example, creates a barrier to backsliding, as does getting commitments in writing."


Use a Multistage Approach to Problem Solving
Watkins writes:



"A related technique to overcome resistance to change is a multistage approach to problem solving. Start by getting people to take part in some shared data collection, for example, on how the organization is performing relative to competition. Oversee the process carefully to be sure that they take a hard look at performance using external comparisons. The key at this stage is to get them to recognize that there is a problem or problems that must be dealt with.

When the task is done, shift the focus to gaining a shared definition of "the problem." What exactly is the problem? Push them hard to engage in root cause analysis, using process analysis tools if helpful. Then get them to work jointly on criteria for evaluating alternative courses of action. What would a 'good' solution look like? How should we measure success?

Finally, use the resulting criteria to evaluate the alternatives. How do the various alternative approaches stack up? By the alternative-evaluation stage of this process, many people will accept outcomes they would have rejected at the outset."

Use Behavior Change to Drive Attitude change
Watkins writes:


"Another entanglement strategy is to use behavior change to drive attitude change. This may sound backwards, but the attitude/behavior-change equation runs both ways. It is possible to alter people's attitudes (with a compelling argument or evocative vision) and thus to change their behavior. But attitude change, and its close organizational cousin cultural change, is difficult to achieve and sustain."

Why Changing Behavior Works
Watkins writes:


"It turns out, interestingly enough, that if you can change people's behavior in desired ways, their attitudes will shift to support the new behavior. This occurs because people feel a strong need to preserve consistency between their behaviors and their beliefs. The implication for persuasion is clear: it often makes sense to focus first on getting people to act in new ways, such as by changing measurement and incentive systems, rather than trying to change their attitudes. If you get them taking the right actions, the right attitudes will follow."

Key Take Ways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Think in terms of gradual change
  • Get incremental buy-in.
  • Change behavior and attitude follows.

My Related Posts

Testing for Expert Judgement

Expert judgement is the ability to make predictions and avoid problems in a given domain.  How can you test the judgement of somebody on your team?  You can observe them over time, or you can accelerate the process by asking them about a topic they are passionate about.  In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about how to test a person's capacity for expert judgement.

Make sure You are Assessing Judgement
Watkins writes:

"Make sure you are assessing judgement and not technical competence or raw intelligence.  Some very bright people have lousy judgement, and some people of average competence have extraordinary judgment.  It is essential to be clear about the mix of knowledge and judgement you need from key people."

Making Predictions and Avoiding Problems
Watkins writes:

"One way to assess judgement is to work with a person for an extended time and observe whether he or she is able to (1) make sound predictions and (2) develop good strategies for avoiding problems.  Both abilities draw on an individual's mental models, or ways of identifying the essential features and dynamics of emerging situations and translating those insights into effective action.  This is what expert judgement is all about.  The problem of course, is that you don't have much time, and it can take a while to find out whether someone did or did not make good predictions.  Fortunately, there are ways you can accelerate this process."

Accelerating Testing for Expert Judgement
Watkins writes:

"One way is to test people's judgement in a domain in which feedback on their prediction abilities will emerge relatively quickly.  Experiment with the following approach.  Ask individuals whose judgement you want to evaluate about a topic that they are passionate about outside work.  It could be politics or cooking or baseball; it doesn't matter.  Challenge them to make predictions: 'Who do you think is going to do better in the debate?' 'What does it take to bake a perfect souffle?' 'Which team will win the game tonight?'  Press them to commit themselves -- unwillingness to go out on a limb is a warning sign in itself.  Then probe why they think their predictions are correct.  Does the rationale make sense?  If possible, follow up to see what happens.

What you are testing is a person's capacity to exercise expert judgement in a particular domain.  Someone who has become an expert in a private domain is likely to have done so in his or her chose field of business too, given enough passion about it.  However you do it, the key is to find ways, beyond just waiting to see how people will perform on the job, to probe for the hallmarks of expertise."

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Expert judgement is the ability to make predictions and avoid problems.
  • Having technical expertise in a domain is not the same as demonstrating sound judgement.
  • Find ways to test for expert judgement beyond waiting to see how people perform on the job.
  • You can speed up the process by asking somebody about an area outside of work and seeing how well they make predictions.

Coalition-Building Cycle

How do you build your support network?  How do you build momentum within your support network?  In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about the coalition-building cycle.

Coalition-Building Cycle
Watkins provides a visual of the coalition-building cycle:

CoallitionBuildingCycle

Coalition-Building Cycle Explained
Watkins outlines the key steps in the coalition-building cycle:

  • Gaining allies helps you recruit others.
  • Recruiting others increases your resource base.
  • Increasing your resource base, increase the likelihood of your agenda's success.
  • Increasing the likelihood of your agenda's success, helps you further in gaining allies.

Persuade Convincibles to Become Supporters
Watkins writes:

"Coalition building entails consolidating existing sources of support while developing relationships with those whose resources or connections you need to succeed.  The sequence in which you consolidate and build support is key.  You will also need to persuade convincibles to become supporters rather than opponents."

Keep Your Allies Up To Date
Watkins writes:

"To consolidate existing support, call on established social and political relationships and strengthen them through regular conversations  Make sure you keep your allies up to date.  Pay attention to how they react to changing conditions.  You can even provide them with advice on how to counter opponent's arguments.  You want to affirm the importance of existing relationships and leverage them into support for your new effort."

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Build momentum by gaining allies.
  • Turn convincibles into supporters before they become opponents.
  • Strengthen your existing support through regular conversations.
  • Provide advice on how to counter opponent's arguments.

My Related Posts

Monday, January 28, 2008

Building Trust on Your Teams

How do you build a team that trusts each other to speak their mind and take risks?  How do you make it possible for the team to engage in passionate and sometimes emotional debate, knowing that they will not be punished for saying something that might otherwise be interpreted as destructive or critical?  It's not about trusting that your team members will behave in a certain way.  It's about building vulnerability-based trust, where it's safe to take risks and face conflict on the team rather than fear it.  In The Five Dysfunctions of a Team: A Leadership Fable, Patrick Lencioni writes about building vulnerability-based trust and overcoming the fear of conflict.

Vulnerability-Based Trust is the Place to Be
I've been on many teams throughout my career and there's a big difference between a team that trusts each other to take risks and speaks their mind versus a team that trusts each other in terms of predicting behavior.  Having experienced both, I know that vulnerability-based trust is the place to be.  I also know that it comes from shared experience over time and through the right behaviors.

My personal  favorites for building vulnerability-based trust include going out to lunch and taking the team off-site.  I prefer to do the off-site earlier versus later so that the team can learn each others' styles and learn the rhythms in a low overhead way.  It's actually a working off-site, where as a team, we kick off the project together in a shared room.  Building the shared experience really helps humanize the relationships and improve understanding across the team.

Vulnerbility-Based Trust
Lencioni writes:

"In the context of building a team, trust is the confidence among team members that their peers' intentions are good, and that there is no reason to be protective or careful around the group.  In essence, teammates must get comfortable being vulnerable with one another."

Standard Definition of Trust
Lencioni writes:

"This description stands in contrast to a more standard definition of trust, one that centers around the ability to predict a person's behavior based on past experience.  For instance, one might 'trust' that a given teammate will produce high-quality work because he has always done so in the past."

Trust and Great Teams
Lencioni writes:

"As desirable as this may be, it is not enough to represent the kind of trust that is characteristic of a great team.  It requires team members to make themselves vulnerable to one another, and be confident that thei respective  vulnerabilities will not be used against them.  The vulnerabilities I'm referring to include weaknesses, skill deficiencies, interpersonal shortcomings, mistakes and requests for help.

As 'soft' as all of this might sound, it is only when team members are truly comfortable being exposed to one another that they begin to act without concern for protecting themselves.  As a result, they can focus their energy and attention completely on the job at hand, rather than on being strategically disingenuous or political with one another."

Achieving Vulnerability-based Trust
Lencioni writes:

"Achieving vulnerability-based trust is difficult because in the course of career-advancement and education, most successful people learn to be competitive with their peers, and protective of their reputations.  It is a challenge for them to turn those instances off for the good of a team, but that is exactly what is required."

The Costs of Failing Are Great
Lencioni writes:

"The costs of failing to do this are great.  Teams that lack trust waste inordinate amounts of time and energy managing their behaviors and interactions within the group.  They tend to dread team meetings, and are reluctant to take risks in asking for or offering assistance to others.  As a result, morale on distrusting teams is usually quite low, and unwanted turnover is high."

How to Build Vulnerability-Based Trust
Lencioni writes:

"Unfortunately, vulnerability-based trust cannot be achieved overnight.  It requires shared experiences over time, multiple instances of follow-through and credibility, and an in-depth understanding of the unique attributes of team members.  However, by taking a focused approach, a team can dramatically accelerate the process and achieve trust in relatively short order."

Tools
Lencioni identifies some tools you can use:

  • Personal histories exercise.  Humanize the relationships by sharing your life stories and backgrounds.
  • Team effectiveness exercise.  Identify the single most important contribution that each of their peers makes to the team, as well as one area that they must improve upon or eliminate for the good of the team.  Focus on one person at a time, starting with the team leader.
  • Personality and behavior preference profiles.  Some of the most effective and lasting tools for building trust on a team are profiles of team member's behavioral preferences and personality styles.  These help break down barriers by allowing people to better understand and empathize with one another.  Lencioni recommends the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) for profiling.
  • 360-degree feedback.  These are riskier than the other tools because they call for peers to make specific judgements and provide one another with constructive criticism.  The key is divorcing it entirely from compensation and formal performance evaluation.  It should allow employees to identify strengths and weaknesses without any repercussions, otherwise it can take on dangerous political undertones.
  • Experiential team exercises.  This includes ropes courses and other experiential team activities.  While they don't always translate directly to the working world, they can be valuable tools for enhancing teamwork as long as they are layered upon more fundamental and relevant processes.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Who's got your back?  One of my colleagues used this as a gut check.  It's amazing how simple, but revealing this simple question can be.  Ask yourself, on your own team, who's got your back?  Who's back do you have?  In your org, who's got your back? ... etc.  Worse, who doesn't have your back?
  • Focus on a supportive, learning environment.  Make it safe for the team to spread their wings.  I'm a fan of learning and growing.  It's tough to grow if you can't take chances.  I find that pairing on the team and using mentors helps a lot.
  • Encourage open and respectful communication.  I think this is critical for the team leader to set the stage for this one.  Asking the right questions and encouraging ideas is the key.
  • The leader has to set the example. By setting the example yourself, you help mold the culture. On example is open, trusting communication. Asking for honest feedback from employees, and then acting on it is another. Examples that run counter: Playing employees off of each other, competition in which the loser gets penalized in some way, public humiliation – as a supposed joke, penalty for honest failure, failure to extend trust – not trusting employees to take initiative and do things right on their own.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Framing Compelling Arguments

How do you create compelling arguments for change? How do you convince others to comply with your requests? How do you reduce the perceived costs of action or increase the perceived costs of inaction? In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about framing compelling arguments.

Reason, Values, or a Combination
Watkins writes:

"Persuasive appeals can be based on logic and data, or on values and the emotions that values elicit, or on some combination thereof. Reason-based arguments have to directly address the pragmatic interests of the people you want to convince. Value-based arguments aim to trigger emotional reflexes -- for example, by evoking patriotism to win support for sacrifices during wartime."

Appealing to Core Values
Watkins summarizes appealing to core values:


Core ValuesWithin the Business Environment
Loyalty
  • Commitment to an ideal
  • Sacrifice to realize that ideal
Commitment and Contribution
  • Service to customers and suppliers
  • Creating a better organization, society, or world
Individual worth and dignity
  • Respect for the individual expressed as elimination of exploitative or patronized practices and promotion of decency and opportunity for all
  • Providing the means for individuals to realize their potential
Integrity
  • Respect for the letter and the spirit of the law
  • Ethical and honest behavior
  • Fairness in all interactions

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Frame your arguments. One approach is to just ask for what you want and see what happens. If the stakes are high, you'll want to frame a compelling argument.
  • Know whether you need logic, emotion or a combination. In general, I find a combination is most effective. That said, some people are more emotionally-driven while others are more data-driven. For those that are more emotionally driven, I find that metaphors or emotional picture words work well. If you know somebody is more data-driven, be sure to do your homework. See Know It Alls.
  • Know an individual's convincer strategy. You need to know the recipe to how an individual gets convinced. See Seven Meta-Programs for Understanding People.
  • Don't misrepresent your argument. There's a difference between improving your argument and manipulation. Present your argument in a compelling, relevant way, but don't mislead. Integrity matters.
  • Know the meta-programs. If you know how people filter the world and what they value, you can make your argument more relevant. See Seven Meta-Programs for Understanding People.
  • Know the Five Thinking Styles. If you know how people think, you can better frame your argument. See Five Thinking Styles.
  • Create a compelling business case. You can use a business case to show how big is the pie and what's your slice. You can use a business case to either support your argument or to argue against an alternative action. See Eight Rules of businessThink.
  • Calculate the impact. This includes the impact over time. Many people are driven by impact. They like to know they make a difference. If you help show them how they will make a difference, this will help you frame a more compelling argument. See Calculating Impact.

My Related Posts

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Action-Forcing Events

How do you get people to take action?  If your results depend on other people, how do you set the stage for action and help build momentum?  In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins write about how to use action-forcing events to help move people into action.

Eliminate Inaction as an Option
Watkins writes:

"How can you get people to take action at all?  It is all too easy even with the best intentions, to defer decisions, delay, and avoid committing scarce resources.  When your success requires the coordinated action of many people, delay by a single individual can have a cascade effect, giving others an excuse not to proceed.  You must therefore eliminate inaction as an option." 

Setting Up Action-Forcing Events
Watkins writes:

"One approach is to set up action-forcing events -- events that induce people to make commitments or take actions.  Those who make commitments should be locked into timetables with incremental implementation milestones.  Meetings, review sessions, and deadlines can all sustain momentum:  Regular meetings to review progress, and tough questioning of those who fail to reach agreed-on goals, increase the psychological pressure to follow through."

Don't Push Them Toward the Opponent Side
Watkins writes:

"Be careful though: Avoid pressing for closure until you are confident the balance of forces acting on key people is tipping your way.  Otherwise, you could succeed in forcing them to take a stand, but inadvertently push them toward the 'opponent' side of the ledger.  Again, you need to rely on your conversations with the people involved and with your 'intelligence network' to get a sense of where the situation stands."

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Identify who does what when.  There's a big difference between agreeing to actions and having owners that are accountable.  There's also a big difference when you have a timeframe for the outcome.
  • Use timetables and incremental milestones.  Rather than wait for a big bang at the end, chunk the work down into increments.  This avoids large surprises downstream. 
  • Leverage review sessions.  Review sessions are a great forcing function.
  • Ask the right questions with the right people in the room.  This is one of the most effective ways to drive results or at least clarify roadblocks and issues.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Three Pillars for Building Self-Efficacy

Self-efficacy is your belief about your ability to influence events that affect your life. Your self-efficacy beliefs determine how you think, feel, motivate yourself, and behave. If you have a strong sense of efficacy, then you approach difficult tasks as challenges to be mastered rather than as threats to be avoided. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about how to build your foundation for self-efficacy.

The Three Pillars of Self-Efficacy
How can you create virtuous cycles that build momentum? How do you avoid vicious cycles that sap your strength? You build a foundation for self-efficacy. Your build your foundation with three pillars.

  • Pillar 1: Adopting Success Strategies.
  • Pillar 2: Enforcing Personal Disciplines.
  • Pillar 3: Building Your Support System.

Pillar 1: Adopting Success Strategies
Watkins outlines the following success strategies:

  • Promote yourself.
  • Accelerate your learning.
  • Match strategy to situation.
  • Secure early wins.
  • Negotiate success.
  • Achieve alignment.
  • Build your team.
  • Create coalitions.

For more information on the strategies, see Ten Key Success Strategies. To see how well your are doing with the strategies, see Checking Whether You're on Track. Also see, Avoiding Vicious Cycles to make sure you're keeping your balance and staying focused on the right things.

Pillar 2: Enforcing Personal Disciplines
Watkins identifies key personal disciplines:

  • Plan to plan.
  • Judiciously defer commitment.
  • Set aside time for the hard work.
  • Go to the balcony.
  • Focus on influence process design.
  • Check in with yourself.
  • Recognize when to quit.

See Guidelines for Structured Reflection.

Pillar 3: Building Your Support System
Watkins identifies the keys to an effective support system:

  • Assert control locally.
  • Stabilize the home front.
  • Build your advice and counsel network.

Quickly setup your basic infrastructure at work, develop your routines and set expectations. This will free you up to work on the tough stuff. Don't let home, rock the boat at work. See Building Your Advice-and-Counsel Network for tips on building your support system.

Key Take Aways
Here's my key take aways:

  • Don't fail at the basics. Get the basics right. Either you master administration or it masters you. This is also a case where a stitch in time saves nine. If you start off on the right foot, you make it easier downstream while folks are making their minds up about you. Impress them up front and life gets easier. You'll build momentum for success if you establish good habits early on.
  • Grow your support system. You can roll with the punches if you have an effective support system.
  • Leverage the success strategies. They're a proven recipe for results.

My Related Posts

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Ten Key Success Strategies

What are the keys to successful transitions into new situations or roles? How do you learn, set priorities, create plans and direct action to build momentum? How do you gain confidence and get energized by your accomplishments? You can adopt a proven set of success strategies. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about ten key strategies that provide a roadmap for success.

Key Success Strategies
Watkins identifies ten key success strategies:

  • Promote yourself.
  • Accelerate your learning.
  • Match strategy to situation.
  • Secure early wins.
  • Negotiate success.
  • Achieve alignment.
  • Build your team.
  • Create coalitions.
  • Keep your balance.
  • Expedite everyone.

Key Success Strategies Explained
Watkins explains the key success strategies:

    • Promote yourself. This doesn't mean hiring your own publicist. It means making the mental break from your old job and preparing to charge in the new one. Perhaps the biggest pitfall you face is assuming that what has made you successful to this point in your career will continue to do so. The dangers of sticking with what you know, working extremely hard at doing it, and failing miserably are very real.
    • Accelerate your learning. You need to climb the learning curve as fast as you can in your new organization. This means understanding its markets, products, technologies, systems, and structures, as well as its culture and politics. Getting acquainted with a new organization can feel like drinking from a fire hose. You have to be systematic and focused about deciding what you need to learn and how you will learn it most efficiently.
    • Match strategy to situation. There are no universal rules for success in transitions. You need to diagnose the business situation accurately and clarify its challenges and opportunities. Start-ups, for instance -- of a new product, process, plant or a completely new business -- share challenges quite different from those you would face while turning around a product, process, or plant in serious trouble. A clear diagnosis of the situation is an essential prerequisite for developing your action plan.
    • Secure early-wins. Early wins build your credibility and create momentum. They create virtuous cycles that leverage the energy you are putting into the organization to create a pervasive sense that good things are happening. In the first few weeks, you need to identify opportunities to build personal credibility. In the first 90 days, you need to identify ways to create value, improve business results, and get to the breakeven point more rapidly.
    • Negotiate success. because no other single relationship is important, you need to figure out how to build a productive relationship with your new boss and manage his or her expectations. This means carefully planning for a series of critical conversations about the situation, expectations, style, resources, and your personal development. Crucially, it means developing and gaining consensus on your 90-day plan.
    • Achieve alignment. The higher you rise in an organization, the more you have to play the role of organizational architect. This means figuring out whether the organization's strategy is around, bringing structure into alignment with its strategy, and developing the systems and skill bases necessary to realize strategic intent.
    • Build your team. If you are inheriting a team, you will need to reevaluate its members and perhaps restructure it to better meet the demands of the situation. Your willingness to make tough early personnel calls and your capacity to select the right people for the right positions is among the most important drivers of success during your transition. You will need to be both systematic and strategic in approaching the team-building challenge.
    • Create coalitions. Your success will depend on your ability to influence people outside your direct line of control. Support alliances, both internal and external, will be necessary to achieve your goals. You should therefore start right away to identify whose support is essential for your success and to figure out how to line them up on your side.
    • Keep your balance. In the personal and professional tumult of a transition, you will have to work hard to maintain your equilibrium and preserve your ability to make good judgements. The risks of losing perspective, getting isolated, and making bad calls are ever present during transitions. There is much you can do to accelerate your personal transition and to gain more control over your work environment. The right advice-and-counsel network is an indispensable resource.
    • Expedite everyone. Finally, you need to help everyone in your organization -- direct reports, bosses, and peers -- accelerate their own transitions. The quicker you can get your new direct reports up to speed, the more you will help your own performance. Beyond that, the benefits to the organization of systematically accelerating everyone's transition are potentially vast.

Assessing Your Success
Now that you know the key success strategies, how do you check whether you're on track? You can use a set of diagnostic questions for checking whether you're on track. What's important is that the sum of strategies is better than the parts. As you put the strategies into practice, make sure you assess your success and tune as appropriate.

Key Take Aways
I find this set of strategies to be very grounded in the real-world. It's not theoretical success -- these strategies work. I've used these strategies on the job for getting results. Here's my key take aways:

  • Know the key success strategies. While this might seem like a large set, it's actually a very concise set that when used together, produces outstanding results.
  • Be flexible and adaptable. The real key here in responding to new challenges is your ability to change your mindset and approach. What got you here won't get you there.
  • Don't go it alone. One of the big mistakes I see on a regular basis, is a smart person with great ideas that doesn't leverage the network. The network either works for you or against you. Why push rocks uphill? You'll also need your network for support when your plans don't go as expected.
  • Keep a balanced scorecard. Turn failure into lessons and keep your wins in mind. Your wins build personal momentum.
  • Focus on the big rocks. The key here is not doing everything that's possible. It's about focusing on the right things. I think the secret here is not only figuring out what your group considers valuable, but making sure that you carve out time to work on the tough stuff. It's all too easy to nail a bunch of little stuff to end up with insignificant results. It's also all to easy to put your all into something, only to find out that the business, your manager or your team doesn't care. Find out what's important and nail that.
  • One size doesn't fit all. The beauty of this collection of strategies is that it's a system for success. It's not a hammer. It's an adaptable framework of approaches and measures that you can leverage to make sure you're doing the right things, the right way, and keeping your balance. I think the biggest insight here is keeping in mind that your people, processes, and products can be in various maturity levels. Diagnosing your portfolio will give you a better vantage point so you choose the right strategies.

My Related Posts

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Checking Whether You're on Track

Are you focused on the right things and balancing the right priorities? How do you gauge your progress towards your targets for success? As a new leader, how do you know whether you're trending in the right direction? In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about questions you can use to determine whether you're building momentum or losing your balance.

Assessment of Core Challenges 
Watkins provides the following questions to serve as your gyroscope for keeping your balance and orientation.

Core Challenge Diagnostic Questions
Promote Yourself Are you adopting the right mind-set for your new job and letting go of the past?
Accelerate your learning Are you figuring out what you need to learn, from whom to learn it, and how to speed up the learning process?
Match strategy to situation Are you diagnosing the type of transition you are facing and the implications for what to do and what not to do?
Secure early wins Are you focusing on the vital priorities that advance long-term goals and build short-term momentum?
Negotiate success Are you building you relationships with your new boss, managing expectations, and marshalling the resources you need?
Achieve alignment Are you identifying and fixing frustrating misalignments of strategy, structure, systems, and skills?
Build your team Are you assessing, restructuring, and aligning your team to leverage what you are trying to accomplish?
Create coalitions Are you building a base of internal and external support for your initiatives so you are not pushing rocks uphill?

Key Take Aways
At the end of the day, the questions help to make sure that you're setting yourself up for success by avoiding common traps.  The big traps include using the wrong strategies, failing to adapt to your new situation, and failing to build an effective support network.  Using the questions above can help make sure you cover your bases.

My Related Posts

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Building Your Advice-and-Counsel Network

How do you build an effective support network for getting results? To be an effective leader, you need a combination of technical advisers, cultural interpreters and political counselors. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about how you can build an effective support network.

Why Build an Advice-and-Counsel Network
Watkins writes:

"No lead, no matter how capable and energetic, can do it all. You need a network of trusted advisers within and outside the organization with whom to talk through what you are experiencing. Your network is an indispensable resource that can help you avoid becoming isolated and losing perspective. As a starting point, you need to cultivate three types of advice givers: technical advisers, cultural interpreters, and political counselors."

Types of Advice Givers
Watkins identifies the types of advice givers and how they help you:

  • Technical advisers. Provide expert analysis of technologies, markets, and strategy. They suggest applications for new technologies. They recommend strategies for entering new markets. They provide timely and accurate information.
  • Cultural interpreters. Help you understand the new culture and (if that is your objective) to adapt for it. They provide you with insight into cultural norms, mental models, and guiding assumptions. They help you learn to speak the language of the new organization.
  • Political counselors. Help you deal with political relationships within your new organization. They help you implement the advice of your technical advisers. They serve as a sounding board as you think through options for implementing your agenda. They challenge you with what-if questions.

Assessment of Your Advice-and-Counsel Network
Watkins provides a table for assessing your advice-and-counsel network:


-Technical AdvisersCultural InterpretersPolitical Counselors
Internal advisers and Counselors (inside your new organization)
External Advisers and Couselors (outside your new organization)

An Effective Support Network
Watkins outlines an effective support network:

  • The right mix of technical advisers, cultural interpreters, and political counselors.
  • The right mix of internal and external advice-givers. You want honest feedback from insiders and the dispassionate perspective of outside observers.
  • External supporters who are loyal to you as an individual, not to your new organization of unit. Typically these are long-standing colleagues and friends.
  • Internal advisers who are trustworthy, whose personal agendas don’t conflict with yours, and who offer straight and accurate advice.
  • Representatives of key constituencies who can help you understand their perspectives. You do not want to restrict yourself to one or two points of view

Internal and External Advice Givers
Watkins writes:

"You also need to think hard about the mix of internal and external advice-givers you want to cultivate. Insiders know the organization, its culture and politics. Seek out people who are well connected and who you can trust to help you grasp what is really going on. They are a priceless resource.

At the same time, insiders cannot be expected to give you dispassionate or disinterested views of events. Thus, you should augment your internal network with outside advisers and counselors who will help you work through the issues and decisions you are facing. They should be skilled at listening and asking questions, have good insight into the way organizations work, and have your best interests at heart."

Think Ahead
Watkins suggests preparing ahead:

"Will your existing network provide the support you need in your new situation? Don’t assume that people who have been helpful in the past will continue to be helpful in your new situation. You will encounter different problems and former advisers may not be able to help you in your new role. As you attain higher levels of responsibility, for example, the need for good political counsel increases dramatically.

You should also be thinking ahead. Because it takes time to develop an effective network, it’s not too early to focus on what sort of network you will need in your next job. How ill your needs for advice change?"

Key Take Aways
I think this is a particularly important post. Too many people with great ideas, can't get results because they don't have an effective network. The other scenario is a great person with a great idea, has to work too hard. An effective network would help both scenarios. Here's my key take aways:

  • Use technical advisers, cultural interpreters, and political counselors. This is a great breakdown. If you have the best of ideas, but you don't have the political support, you won't get your ideas implemented.
  • Include internal and external advisers. Keeping a set of external advisers will help you keep perspective. Otherwise, you can end up the frog in the boiling pot.
  • Don't just rely on your past network. Situations change. Needs change. Evolve your network for your changing needs.
  • Build your network before you need it. While a friend in need is a friend indeed, building your support network ahead of time will help you avoid desperation. Also, building an effective network takes time.

My Related Posts

Sunday, January 13, 2008

Avoiding Vicious Cycles

If you're a new leader, how do you know if you're working on the right things and keeping your balance?  What are your key gauges to make sure you're not falling into personal traps?   In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about the traps you can fall into, and the questions to help you stay self-aware.

Self-Check
Watkins provides a set of self-check questions.  When you ask yourself the following questions, pay particular attention to where you agree or strongly agree:

  • Am I very busy but not finding time for the most important things I ought to be doing?
  • Am I doing things I should not be doing at the request of others (e.g. my boss, my direct reports)?
  • Am I frustrated that I cannot get things done the way I want them to be done?
  • Do I feel isolated in the organization?
  • Does my judgement seems off these days?
  • Am I avoiding making tough decisions on key issues (e.g. personnel)?
  • Do I have less energy for work than I usually do?

Where you agree or strongly agree, these are potential flags.

Personal Traps
Watkins identifies seven personal traps that correspond to the self-check questions above:

  • Riding off in all directions.
  • Undefended boundaries.
  • Brittleness.
  • Isolation.
  • Biased judgement.
  • Work avoidance.
  • Going over the top.

Riding Off in all Directions
Watkins writes:

"You can't hope to focus others if you can't focus yourself.  You can be busy and still fail every single day.  Why? Because there is an infinite number of tasks you could do during your transition, but only a few that are vital.  Perhaps you tell yourself, "If I get enough things going, something has to click," and dissipate your efforts.  Perhaps you over-estimate your capacity to keep all the balls in the air.  Every new leader has to do some parallel processing.  But it is easy to reach the point of mental lock-up, where you find yourself pulled form task to task faster than you can refocus on each new one.  Whatever the explanation, if important problems remain unaddressed, they could explode and suck up more of your time, leaving you even less time, and so on.  The result is a vicious cycle of firefighting."

Undefended Boundaries
Watkins writes:

"If you fail to establish solid boundaries defining what you are willing and not willing to do, the people around you -- bosses, peers, and direct reports -- will take whatever you have to give.  The more you give, the less they will respect you and the more they will ask of you -- another vicious cycle.  Eventually you will feel angry and resentful that you are being nibbled to death, but you will have no one to blame but yourself.  If you cannot establish boundaries for yourself, you cannot expect others to do it for you."

Brittleness
Watkins writes:

"The uncertainty inherent in transitions breeds rigidity and defensiveness, especially in new leaders with a high need for control.  The likely result: overcommitment to a failing course of action.  You make a call prematurely and then feel unable to back away from it without losing credibility.  The longer you wait, the harder it is to admit you were wrong and the more calamitous the consequences.  Or perhaps you decide that your way of accomplishing a particular goal is the only way.  as a result your rigidity disempowers people who have equally valid ideas about how to achieve the same goal."

Isolation
Watkins writes:

"To be effective, you have to be connected to the people who make action happen and to the subterranean flow of information.  It is surprisingly easy for new leaders to end up isolated, and isolation can creep up on you.  It happens because you don't take the time to make the right connections, perhaps by relying overmuch on a few people or on "official" information.  It also happens if you unintentionally discourage people from sharing critical information with you.  Perhaps they fear your reaction to bad news, or see you as having been captured by competing interests.  whatever the reason, isolation breeds uninformed decision making, which damages your credibility and further reinforces your isolation."

Biased Judgement
Watkins writes:

"Biased judgement -- a loss of perspective because of well recognized weaknesses in human decision making -- can take several forms.  Overcommitment to a failing course of action because of ego and credibility is one version.  Others include confirmation bias, the tendency to focus on information that confirms your beliefs and filter out what does not; self-serving illusions, a tendency for your personal stake in a situation to cloud your judgement; and optimize overconfidence, or underestimation of the difficulties associated with your preferred course of action.  Vulnerability to these biases is a constant, but you are particularly at risk when the stakes get higher, uncertainty and ambiguity increase, and emotions run high."

Work Avoidance
Watkins writes:

"You will have to make tough calls early in your new job.  Perhaps you have to make major decisions about the direction of the business based on incomplete information.  Or perhaps your personnel decisions will have a profound impact on people's lives.  Consciously or unconsciously, you may choose to delay by burying yourself in other work or fooling yourself that the time isn't ripe to make the call.  Ron Heifetz uses the term work avoidance to characterize this tendency to avoid taking the bull by the horns, which results in tough problems becoming even tougher."

Going Over the Top
Watkins writes:

"All of these traps can generate dangerous levels of stress.  Not all stress is bad.  In fact, there is a well-documented relationship between stress and performance known as the Yerkes-Dodson curve."

Key Take Aways
This is a gem.  Watkins did a great job outlining, but I'll summarize this to say that focus, boundaries, flexibility, and balance are key.  So is knowing your capacity, building a great personal sounding board for your decisions, and making sure that you grow your network where you need to.

My Related Posts

Saturday, January 5, 2008

Superordinate Goals

How do you get competitive groups to work with each other? How do you improve cross-group collaboration? Superordinate goals. In Social Psychology: Theories, Research, and Applications, Robert S. Feldman writes about how superordinate goals were effective in uniting competitive groups.

Two Groups in the Same Camp
Feldman writes:

"One of the best examples of how group goals can influence group formation comes from a now-classic field study held in a boy’s summer camp named Robber’s Cave (Sherif, 1966). Two groups of missle-class 11- and 12-year-olds – none of whom knew that he was in an experiment – were settled in opposite sides of the camp. Each group was unaware of the other group’s existence. To develop the two campsites into groups, the experimenters arranged for the boys to engage in activities that could only be carried out by group efforts, such as carrying a heavy canoe into the water or cleaning a dirty beach so that it was suitable for
use. Quite soon, each campsite evolved into what could clearly be called a group. They gave themselves names (the “Rattlers” and the “Eagles”) and they developed particular patterns and standards of behavior unique to each group."
Wicked, Disturbed and Vicious
Feldman writes:

"Once the two groups had been established, the experiments tried to develop competition. To do this, they developed a tournament of games in which the two groups competed for a series of prizes that only one group could win. The researchers got more than they bargained for: beyond the tournament. The groups picked fights, raided each other’s campsights, and generally behaved in a manner that lead the researchers to feel that, to an outside observer, the children appeared as “wicked, disturbed, and vicious bunches of youngsters” (Sherif, 1966, p. 58). "

Superordinate Goals
Feldman writes:

"In an attempt to reduce the intergroup conflict, the experimenters at first tried a number of strategies that proved ineffective. Arranging for pleasant experiences, such as watching a movie, only provoked more fighting as soon as the lights were dimmed. Moral exhortation proved useless. Even the introduction of a third group, which was supposed to act as a kind of common enemy, was ineffective. One thing did work, however: the introduction of a superordinate goal. Reasoning that it was common goals that led to the formation of the groups initially, the researchers thought that the introduction of goals that were common to both groups – superordinate goals – might be effective in uniting the two groups. This time, they were right. "

Crisis Brings the Groups Together
Feldman writes:
"The experimenters arranged for a series of emergencies. For instance, the water supply broke down, and the boys had to work jointly if they wanted to have water to drink. After a number of such events, group hostility was eventually reduced, friendships developed across group lines, and the superordinate goals became effective in unifying the previously hostile groups."

Key Take Aways
I think we've all seen crisis bring folks together. At work I often run into groups competing against each other for limited resources or territory. Common goals are a higher level bring groups together. When that's not possible, it's important to take away the threat, to reduce cross-group hostility. One way to do this, if the space is large enough, is to carve out a niche, to reduce the turf wars. Everybody gets a place to play and they respect each other's boundaries.

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Guidelines for Structured Reflection

If you use weekly structured reflection, you can see the patterns in the problems you face and how you solve them. You'll be able to see how your responses change over time. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins suggest setting aside 15 minutes at the end of each week and to reflect on the following questions:

What do you feel so far?

  • On a scale of high to low, do you feel:
  • Excited? If not, why not? What can you do about it?
  • Confident? If not, why not? What can you do about it?
  • In control of your success? If not, why not? what can you do about it?

What has bothered you so far?

  • With whom have you failed to connect? Why?
  • Of the meetings you have attended, which has been the most troubling? Why?
  • Of all that you have seen or heard, what has disturbed you most? Why?

What has gone well or poorly?

  • Which interactions would you handled differently if you could? Which exceeded your expectations? Why?
  • Which of your decisions have turned out particularly well? Not so well? Why?
  • What missed opportunities do you regret the most? Was a better result blocked by you or by something beyond your control?

Are You as Proactive as You Can Be?
Michael Watkins writes:

"Now focus on the biggest challenges or difficulties you are facing. Be honest with yourself. Are your difficulties situational or do their sources lie within you? Even experienced and skilled people blame problems on the situation rather than their own actions. The net effect is that they are less proactive than they could be."

Key Take Aways
I'm a fan of reflection. I think it can help you avoid being the frog in the boiling pot (that doesn't know when to get out.) I think the trick is using the right sets of questions. I particularly like the fact that Michael includes a question focused on how you feel, right up front. I think it's easy to get wrapped up in logic and miss what your gut might be trying to tell you.

Monday, December 31, 2007

Sequencing to Build Momentum

Who you influence and in what sequence matters. People are heavily influenced by their social networks. Monkey see, monkey do. This can work for or against you. The key is to get the right people on your side. If you're doing a project proposal or pitching an idea, who you pitch it to and in what sequence matters. You can either stack the deck in your favor and build momentum, or you can fight an uphill battle. In The First 90 Days: Critical Success Strategies for New Leaders at All Levels, Michael Watkins writes about sequencing to build momentum.

Formidable Barrier or Valuable Asset
Influence networks can be barriers or assets. Watkins writes:

"As we have seen, people consistently look to others in their social networks for clues about 'right thinking,' and defer others with expertise or status on particular sets of issues. The resulting influence networks can be a formidable barrier to your efforts or a valuable asset, or both."

Example of Social Influence
Watkins provides an example of social influence showing how a group is persuaded:

"Let us return once more to the example of asking a group of people to do something embarrassing. Suppose that, in response to my request, a respected member of the group said, "No way, I'm doing that. It is disrespectful and foolish." Almost certainly no one else in the group would do what I had asked. But suppose the same person jumped up, grabbed someone else and said, "Let's do it! It'll be fun!" The odds are that everyone else would eventually follow suit. In fact, the last to rise, would feel social pressure to do so: "What's the matter with you?"

Now suppose I did an analysis of the group before this exercise and identified the most respected person. Suppose I met with that person before the exercise and enlisted his or her aid as a confederate to make some important points about group dynamics and social influence. The odds are good that this person would agree to do so - and that others would follow."

Sequencing Strategy
Gain respected allies early on. Watkins writes:

"The fundamental insight is that you can leverage knowledge of influence networks into disproportionate influence on a group with what my colleague Jim Sebenius termed a sequencing strategy. The order in which you approach potential allies and convincables will have a decisive impact on your coalition-building efforts. Why? Once you gain a respected ally, you will typically find it easier to recruit others. As you recruit more allies, your resource base grows. With broader support, the likelihood increases that your agenda will succeed. That optimistic outlook makes it easier to recruit still more supporters.

If you approach the right people first, you can set in motion a virtuous cycle. Therefore you need to decide carefully who you wil approach first, and how you will do it."

Who to Focus On
Watkins suggests focusing on the following first:
  • People with whom you already have supportive relationships.
  • Individuals whose interests are strongly compatible with yours.
  • People who have the critical resources you need to make your agenda succeed.
  • People with important connections who can recruit more supporters.

Key Take Aways
I have several large-scale projects under my belt so I can say with confidence that sequence matters. Here's my key take aways:

  • Build incremental support. Divide and conquer. You don't need to win everybody over at once. In fact, unless it's a sure thing, you probably won't.
  • Tackle your most influential critics first. This serves three purposes. First, it will expose you to some issues you may need to work through. Second, if you get them on your side, it sends a powerful message, helping you get more supporters. Third, it helps mitigate the risk that a powerful critic will derail your momentum downstream. Put it another way, a stitch in time, saves nine.
  • Know when you're not the right person. If you don't have rapport with the people you need on your side, but one of your allies does, see how you can leverage them.
  • Don't get blind-sided by social influence. The best ideas can get shot down, regardless of their merits. It's sad, but true. If you purely focus on the results, but ignore the people mechanics, you can fail. Even if you don't, you can find yourself working harder than you should need to.
  • Consider an exec sponsor. The social influence of the right exec sponsor can carry you over the hurdles, as well as help shape the support all around you.

My Related Posts